Jump to content

Index S2

From Garmin Wiki
(Redirected from Garmin Index S2)
Index S2
The Garmin Index S2 in white and black, showing the weigh-in display and per-user identification
General Information
Manufacturer Garmin
Type Wi‑Fi Smart Scale / Body Composition Monitor
Series Index Series
Release Date October 14, 2020
Discontinued No
Price $149.99 (USD MSRP)
Predecessor Index Smart Scale
Colors Black, White
Display
Type High-resolution color LCD
Physical
Case Size 320 × 310 × 28 mm (12.6 × 12.2 × 1.1 in)
Weight 2.0 kg (70.4 oz)
Features
Sensors Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) electrodes
Connectivity Wi‑Fi (802.11 b/g/n), Bluetooth Smart
Key Features Weight, weight trend, BMI, body fat %, body water %, skeletal muscle mass, bone mass; weather widget; up to 16 users; automatic Wi‑Fi sync to Garmin Connect
Related Index Smart Scale, Index BPM, Garmin Connect

The Garmin Index S2 is a Wi‑Fi-connected smart scale and body-composition monitor announced by Garmin on October 14, 2020.[1] It is the second-generation Index Series scale, succeeding the original Index Smart Scale, and adds a high-resolution color display, a weight-trend graph, and customizable on-scale widgets while retaining the same $149.99 launch price.[1][2]

Like its predecessor, the Index S2 measures weight, body mass index (BMI), body fat percentage, body water percentage, skeletal muscle mass, and bone mass, and automatically uploads each weigh-in to Garmin Connect over Wi‑Fi without requiring a phone nearby.[1] Body-composition figures are estimated using foot-to-foot bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). The scale supports up to 16 users and identifies each one automatically.[3]

Overview

The Index S2 is Garmin's second-generation connected scale and the hub of the Index Series body-metrics lineup. It is aimed primarily at users already invested in the Garmin ecosystem: each weigh-in syncs automatically to Garmin Connect over Wi‑Fi, so weight and body-composition data sit alongside the activity, sleep, and training metrics from a paired Garmin watch or bike computer. At a $149.99 launch price — unchanged from the original — it sits at the premium end of the consumer smart-scale market, competing with devices such as the Withings Body series.[4]

What's New Over the Index Smart Scale

Compared with the original Index Smart Scale, the Index S2 introduced:[1][3]

  • High-resolution color display (replacing the original's dot-matrix LCD)
  • Weight trend graph — an on-scale 30-day line graph of weight readings
  • Weigh-in difference — shows the change since the previous weigh-in, aimed at athletes monitoring hydration
  • Weather widget and other customizable widgets that can be toggled on or off
  • Slimmer profile and refreshed industrial design

Measured Metrics

The Index S2 displays and records:[2][4]

  • Weight (pounds, kilograms, or stones) and weight trend
  • Body Mass Index (BMI)
  • Body fat percentage
  • Body water percentage
  • Skeletal muscle mass
  • Bone mass

Body-composition values are derived from foot-to-foot bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA), in which a low-level electrical current passes up one leg and down the other; tissue resistance is then run through Garmin's algorithms to estimate composition.[4] Because BIA is influenced by the user's activity level, Garmin Connect includes an activity class setting (and, in later app versions, the ability to manually set a known body-composition value) that adjusts the estimates.[3] If a user steps on the scale wearing socks, a question-mark icon appears and only weight and BMI are recorded.[4] Garmin advises that people with pacemakers or other implanted electronic devices should not use the scale, and that pregnant users should consult a doctor; unlike some competitors, the Index S2 has no dedicated pregnancy or baby mode.[4]

Design and Hardware

The Index S2 is a tempered-glass scale available in black and white, with a slimmer profile than the original. It measures roughly 320 × 310 × 28 mm (12.6 × 12.2 × 1.1 in) and weighs about 2.0 kg (70.4 oz), supporting a maximum capacity of 181 kg (400 lb).[4] It is powered by four AAA batteries (included), rated for up to nine months, and ships with risers for use on carpet. A toggle on the underside switches between pounds, kilograms, and stones.[3][1]

Connectivity and Setup

Initial setup is done through the Garmin Connect app over Bluetooth, after which the scale connects to Wi‑Fi (802.11 b/g/n, 2.4 GHz) and uploads weigh-ins automatically without a phone present.[5] The scale can store up to seven Wi‑Fi networks, allowing it to be used across multiple locations; only the device owner can add networks.[5] The scale is woken by tapping it with a foot before stepping on.[4]

Multi-User Support

The Index S2 supports up to 16 users (the owner plus 15 invited connections in Garmin Connect). It automatically distinguishes users based on weight and usage frequency and displays each person's name or initials (up to four characters) during the weigh-in; users can also manually switch by tapping the scale with the right foot.[3] Each user's data syncs to their own Garmin Connect account.

Garmin Connect Integration

Weigh-ins sync to Garmin Connect, where users can review weight, BMI, body fat, body water, skeletal muscle mass, and bone mass over day, week, month, and year views, along with averages and trends. Multiple weigh-ins per day are preserved rather than overwritten.[3] Garmin Connect can link with MyFitnessPal and Strava, and weight data can feed a paired Garmin watch or bike computer for more accurate calorie calculations.[4][6]

Specifications

Specification Detail
Announced October 14, 2020
Launch price $149.99 (USD MSRP)
Colors Black, White
Display High-resolution color LCD
Dimensions 320 × 310 × 28 mm (12.6 × 12.2 × 1.1 in)
Weight 2.0 kg (70.4 oz)
Maximum capacity 181 kg (400 lb)
Units Pounds, kilograms, stones
Metrics Weight, weight trend, BMI, body fat %, body water %, skeletal muscle mass, bone mass
Body composition Foot-to-foot bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA)
Connectivity Wi‑Fi 802.11 b/g/n (2.4 GHz), Bluetooth Smart
Wi‑Fi networks stored Up to 7
Users supported Up to 16
Power 4 × AAA batteries (included), ~9 months
Platform Garmin Connect (also MyFitnessPal, Strava)

Reception

Reviews praised the Index S2's build quality and Garmin-ecosystem integration while questioning its value. Tom's Guide called it "a well-built, premium-looking smart scale that measures everything" but concluded it "under-delivers for this price point," citing the lack of a pregnancy or baby mode, a companion app that "doesn't add much" beyond what the scale already shows, limited third-party connectivity, a glass surface that is hard to keep clean, and app pairing errors during testing.[4] The reviewer also criticized Garmin's encouragement to weigh in multiple times per day as potentially fostering an unhealthy relationship with the scale.[4]

In his review, DesFit described the scale as "honestly quite gorgeous" and its readings as consistent between back-to-back weigh-ins, but noted that as a lean athlete his body-fat reading came in several points high (12–13% versus a DEXA-measured 8–10%), even after adjusting his activity class.[3]

Accuracy and Reliability Concerns

The Index S2's body-composition accuracy has been a persistent and widely reported point of criticism. Numerous owners on Garmin's own support forums report body-fat, muscle, and bone readings that differ substantially from clinical references such as DEXA scans and caliper tests — in some cases by 8–10 percentage points or more — with several long-running threads on the topic later locked by moderators.[7][8] Commonly suggested workarounds include setting the activity/athlete class to its upper range and manually entering a known body-composition value in Garmin Connect to recalibrate the estimate; owners report mixed results from both.[9]

A separate recurring complaint concerns Wi‑Fi connectivity and syncing. Owners report scales that intermittently fail to connect, drop their network, or stop syncing — in a number of cases following firmware updates, with reports of "No Networks Found" and "Invalid Password" errors after software version 3.00.[10]

Class-Action Lawsuit

On May 29, 2026, a proposed class-action lawsuit was filed against Garmin in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois over the Index S2's body-composition accuracy.[11] The case, Maurer v. Garmin International, Inc. et al (No. 1:26-cv-06389), names Garmin International, Garmin USA, and Garmin Ltd. as defendants and was brought by the law firms Lee Segui PLLC and Pearson Warshaw LLP. The named plaintiff, Victor Maurer of Mount Prospect, Illinois, says he bought the scale in August 2024 for $149.99 and later found its body-fat and BMI readings differed significantly from a DEXA scan.[11]

The complaint alleges "Deceptive Biometric Marketing," arguing that the foot-to-foot BIA technology "is incapable of accurate body composition measurements," which it says makes Garmin's marketing of the scale as "accurate" false and misleading. It cites a 2021 study in JMIR mHealth and uHealth that found foot-to-foot scales underestimated fat and muscle mass by as much as roughly 8 kg (about 8 percentage points) versus DEXA, and a 2022 study in the British Journal of Nutrition finding differences of up to 5 percentage points; neither study tested the Index S2 specifically. The complaint concedes the scale is "likely as reliable as traditional scales" for plain weight and attributes the body-composition problem to inherent "limitations in BIA technology" shared across consumer smart scales.[11]

The suit brings six causes of action — including violations of Illinois consumer-fraud and deceptive-trade-practices statutes, common-law fraud, breach of warranty, and unjust enrichment — and seeks class certification, damages, restitution, an injunction against the marketing, and a declaration that the scale "cannot accurately measure body composition," with an amount in controversy exceeding $5 million.[11]

The allegations have not been proven in court, and Garmin had not responded to the suit as of the initial reporting.[11]

See Also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 "Measure more with the Index S2 smart scale from Garmin". Garmin Newsroom. October 14, 2020. Retrieved June 2026
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 "Garmin Index S2". Garmin. Retrieved June 2026
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 DesFit."Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale Review". October 14, 2020. Retrieved June 2026
  4. ↑ 4.00 4.01 4.02 4.03 4.04 4.05 4.06 4.07 4.08 4.09 Nikita Achanta."Garmin Index S2 review". Tom's Guide. April 30, 2024. Retrieved June 2026
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 "Index S2 Smart Scale Owner's Manual — Setting Up Your Device". Garmin. Retrieved June 2026
  6. ↑ Ray Maker."Garmin Index S2 Scale In-Depth Review". DC Rainmaker. October 14, 2020. Retrieved June 2026
  7. ↑ "Body Fat percentage wildly inaccurate, firmware algorithm update needed?". Garmin Forums. Retrieved June 2026
  8. ↑ "S2 Body Fat not accurate". Garmin Forums. Retrieved June 2026
  9. ↑ "Index S2 Inaccurate BF, Water — manual input fixed problem". Garmin Forums. Retrieved June 2026
  10. ↑ "After SW 3.00 — No Networks Found / Invalid Password / blinking WiFi icon". Garmin Forums. Retrieved June 2026
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 Billy Grenis."Garmin Faces Class-Action Lawsuit Over Index S2 Smart Scale Body-Fat Accuracy". Garmin Rumors. June 4, 2026. Retrieved June 2026
Garmin Wiki
A project by GarminRumors.com